diff mbox series

stdlib: Reinstate stable mergesort implementation on qsort

Message ID 20231206202228.1842209-1-adhemerval.zanella@linaro.org
State Superseded
Headers show
Series stdlib: Reinstate stable mergesort implementation on qsort | expand

Commit Message

Adhemerval Zanella Dec. 6, 2023, 8:22 p.m. UTC
The mergesort removal from qsort implementation (commit 03bf8357e8)
had the side-effect of making sorting nonstable.  Although neither
POSIX nor C standard specify that qsort should be stable, it seems
that it has become an instance of Hyrum's law where multiple programs
expect it.

Also, the resulting introsort implementation is not faster than
the previous mergesort (which makes the change even less appealing).

This patch restores the previous mergesort implementation, with the
exception of machinery that checks the resulting allocation against
the _SC_PHYS_PAGES (it only adds complexity and the heuristic not
always make sense depending on the system configuration and load).
The alloca usage was replaced with a fixed-size buffer.

For the fallback mechanism, the implementation uses heapsort.  It is
simpler than quicksort, the performance should be similar, and it
does not suffer from adversarial inputs.  Also, with memory overcommit,
it should be rarely triggered.

The drawback is mergesort requires O(n) extra space, and since it is
allocated with malloc the function is AS-signal-unsafe.  It should be
feasible to change it to use mmap, although I am not sure how urgent
it is.  The heapsort is also nonstable, so programs that require a
stable sort would still be subject to this latent issue.

Checked on x86_64-linux-gnu and aarch64-linux-gnu.
---
 manual/argp.texi    |   2 +-
 manual/locale.texi  |   2 +-
 manual/search.texi  |   7 +-
 stdlib/Makefile     |   2 +-
 stdlib/qsort.c      | 470 +++++++++++++++++++++-----------------------
 stdlib/tst-qsort4.c |  25 +--
 stdlib/tst-qsort5.c |  71 ++++++-
 7 files changed, 296 insertions(+), 283 deletions(-)

Comments

Zack Weinberg Dec. 6, 2023, 9:11 p.m. UTC | #1
On Wed, Dec 6, 2023, at 3:22 PM, Adhemerval Zanella wrote:
...
> The drawback is mergesort requires O(n) extra space, and since it is
> allocated with malloc the function is AS-signal-unsafe.  It should be
> feasible to change it to use mmap, although I am not sure how urgent
> it is.  The heapsort is also nonstable, so programs that require a
> stable sort would still be subject to this latent issue.

It might be worthwhile investigating "block sort" aka "grail sort", which
is merge sort modified to be in-place and stable via clever reshuffling of
the input array.  For experimental purposes we could drop in either of
these implementations (one is Unlicense and the other is MIT):

https://github.com/BonzaiThePenguin/WikiSort
https://github.com/HolyGrailSortProject/Rewritten-Grailsort

zw
Florian Weimer Dec. 8, 2023, 4:17 p.m. UTC | #2
* Adhemerval Zanella:

>  stdlib/tst-qsort5.c |  71 ++++++-

This test no longer tests anything close to what was originally
intended.  The initial comment is now wrong because we no longer produce
an order adversarial to quicksort—there is no quicksort left.

I'm still reviewing this patch otherwise, but it's quite difficult.

Thanks,
Florian
Florian Weimer Dec. 8, 2023, 4:42 p.m. UTC | #3
* Adhemerval Zanella:

> -heapsort_r (void *base, void *end, size_t size, enum swap_type_t swap_type,
> -	    __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
> +heapsort_r (void *base, size_t n, size_t size, __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
>  {
> -  size_t n = ((uintptr_t) end - (uintptr_t) base) / size;
>    if (n <= 1)
> -    /* Handled by insertion sort.  */
>      return;
>  
> +  enum swap_type_t swap_type;
> +  if (is_aligned (base, size, 8))
> +    swap_type = SWAP_WORDS_64;
> +  else if (is_aligned (base, size, 4))
> +    swap_type = SWAP_WORDS_32;
> +  else
> +    swap_type = SWAP_BYTES;

Shouldn't this use msort_swap_type?

Thanks,
Florian
Florian Weimer Dec. 8, 2023, 5:36 p.m. UTC | #4
* Adhemerval Zanella:

> +static void
> +indirect_msort_with_tmp (const struct msort_param *p, void *b, size_t n,
> +			 size_t s)
> +{
> +  /* Indirect sorting.  */
> +  char *ip = (char *) b;
> +  void **tp = (void **) (p->t + n * sizeof (void *));
> +  void **t = tp;
> +  void *tmp_storage = (void *) (tp + n);


> +	memcpy (tmp_storage, ip, s);


>  __qsort_r (void *const pbase, size_t total_elems, size_t size,
>  	   __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
>  {
>    if (total_elems <= 1)
>      return;
>  
> +  char tmp[QSORT_STACK_SIZE];
> +  size_t total_size = total_elems * size;
> +  char *buf;

I don't see how the total_size computation makes sure that
the tmp_storage place actually exists when …

> +  if (total_size < sizeof buf)
> +    buf = tmp;
> +  else
> +    {
> +      int save = errno;
> +      buf = malloc (total_size);
> +      __set_errno (save);
> +      if (buf == NULL)
> +	{
> +	  /* Fallback to heapsort in case of memory failure.  */
> +	  heapsort_r (pbase, total_elems - 1, size, cmp, arg);
> +	  return;
> +	}
> +    }
>  
> +  if (size > INDIRECT_SORT_SIZE_THRES)
>      {
> +      const struct msort_param msort_param =
> +	{
> +	  .s = sizeof (void *),
> +	  .cmp = cmp,
> +	  .arg = arg,
> +	  .var = SWAP_VOID_ARG,
> +	  .t = buf,
> +	};
> +      indirect_msort_with_tmp (&msort_param, pbase, total_elems, size);

it is passed to indirect_msort_with_tmp here.

Thanks,
Florian
Adhemerval Zanella Jan. 2, 2024, 1:03 p.m. UTC | #5
On 08/12/23 13:17, Florian Weimer wrote:
> * Adhemerval Zanella:
> 
>>  stdlib/tst-qsort5.c |  71 ++++++-
> 
> This test no longer tests anything close to what was originally
> intended.  The initial comment is now wrong because we no longer produce
> an order adversarial to quicksort—there is no quicksort left.
> 
> I'm still reviewing this patch otherwise, but it's quite difficult.

Indeed, and it is already ineffective because it would not generate an 
adversarial with current introsort implementation either.  I though about 
pre-generate an input, but it would be a large file and/or require to keep 
the generator somewhere and depending of the input size it would require a 
lot of time (on my workstation, an input with 150000 takes about 5s using 
the old quicksort implementation, and all inputs used on tst-qsort5 takes
about 26s).

I will remove this test in the next version.
Adhemerval Zanella Jan. 2, 2024, 1:18 p.m. UTC | #6
On 08/12/23 13:42, Florian Weimer wrote:
> * Adhemerval Zanella:
> 
>> -heapsort_r (void *base, void *end, size_t size, enum swap_type_t swap_type,
>> -	    __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
>> +heapsort_r (void *base, size_t n, size_t size, __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
>>  {
>> -  size_t n = ((uintptr_t) end - (uintptr_t) base) / size;
>>    if (n <= 1)
>> -    /* Handled by insertion sort.  */
>>      return;
>>  
>> +  enum swap_type_t swap_type;
>> +  if (is_aligned (base, size, 8))
>> +    swap_type = SWAP_WORDS_64;
>> +  else if (is_aligned (base, size, 4))
>> +    swap_type = SWAP_WORDS_32;
>> +  else
>> +    swap_type = SWAP_BYTES;
> 
> Shouldn't this use msort_swap_type?

We can use it for both algorithm, I will change it.
Adhemerval Zanella Jan. 2, 2024, 1:26 p.m. UTC | #7
On 08/12/23 14:36, Florian Weimer wrote:
> * Adhemerval Zanella:
> 
>> +static void
>> +indirect_msort_with_tmp (const struct msort_param *p, void *b, size_t n,
>> +			 size_t s)
>> +{
>> +  /* Indirect sorting.  */
>> +  char *ip = (char *) b;
>> +  void **tp = (void **) (p->t + n * sizeof (void *));
>> +  void **t = tp;
>> +  void *tmp_storage = (void *) (tp + n);
> 
> 
>> +	memcpy (tmp_storage, ip, s);
> 
> 
>>  __qsort_r (void *const pbase, size_t total_elems, size_t size,
>>  	   __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
>>  {
>>    if (total_elems <= 1)
>>      return;
>>  
>> +  char tmp[QSORT_STACK_SIZE];
>> +  size_t total_size = total_elems * size;
>> +  char *buf;
> 
> I don't see how the total_size computation makes sure that
> the tmp_storage place actually exists when …
> 
>> +  if (total_size < sizeof buf)
>> +    buf = tmp;
>> +  else
>> +    {
>> +      int save = errno;
>> +      buf = malloc (total_size);
>> +      __set_errno (save);
>> +      if (buf == NULL)
>> +	{
>> +	  /* Fallback to heapsort in case of memory failure.  */
>> +	  heapsort_r (pbase, total_elems - 1, size, cmp, arg);
>> +	  return;
>> +	}
>> +    }
>>  
>> +  if (size > INDIRECT_SORT_SIZE_THRES)
>>      {
>> +      const struct msort_param msort_param =
>> +	{
>> +	  .s = sizeof (void *),
>> +	  .cmp = cmp,
>> +	  .arg = arg,
>> +	  .var = SWAP_VOID_ARG,
>> +	  .t = buf,
>> +	};
>> +      indirect_msort_with_tmp (&msort_param, pbase, total_elems, size);
> 
> it is passed to indirect_msort_with_tmp here.

Indeed, I forgot to add the previous check for the indirect sorting:

  if (size > INDIRECT_SORT_SIZE_THRES)
    total_size = 2 * total_elems * sizeof (void *) + size;

I will send an updated version.
diff mbox series

Patch

diff --git a/manual/argp.texi b/manual/argp.texi
index b77ad68285..0023441812 100644
--- a/manual/argp.texi
+++ b/manual/argp.texi
@@ -735,7 +735,7 @@  for options, bad phase of the moon, etc.
 @c  hol_set_group ok
 @c   hol_find_entry ok
 @c  hol_sort @mtslocale @acucorrupt
-@c   qsort dup
+@c   qsort dup @acucorrupt
 @c    hol_entry_qcmp @mtslocale
 @c     hol_entry_cmp @mtslocale
 @c      group_cmp ok
diff --git a/manual/locale.texi b/manual/locale.texi
index f6afa5dc44..1b3f97839b 100644
--- a/manual/locale.texi
+++ b/manual/locale.texi
@@ -253,7 +253,7 @@  The symbols in this section are defined in the header file @file{locale.h}.
 @c    calculate_head_size ok
 @c    __munmap ok
 @c    compute_hashval ok
-@c    qsort dup
+@c    qsort dup @acucorrupt
 @c     rangecmp ok
 @c    malloc @ascuheap @acsmem
 @c    strdup @ascuheap @acsmem
diff --git a/manual/search.texi b/manual/search.texi
index a550858478..5691bf2f2b 100644
--- a/manual/search.texi
+++ b/manual/search.texi
@@ -159,7 +159,7 @@  To sort an array using an arbitrary comparison function, use the
 
 @deftypefun void qsort (void *@var{array}, size_t @var{count}, size_t @var{size}, comparison_fn_t @var{compare})
 @standards{ISO, stdlib.h}
-@safety{@prelim{}@mtsafe{}@assafe{}@acsafe{}}
+@safety{@prelim{}@mtsafe{}@assafe{}@acunsafe{@acucorrupt{}}}
 The @code{qsort} function sorts the array @var{array}.  The array
 contains @var{count} elements, each of which is of size @var{size}.
 
@@ -199,8 +199,9 @@  Functions}):
 The @code{qsort} function derives its name from the fact that it was
 originally implemented using the ``quick sort'' algorithm.
 
-The implementation of @code{qsort} in this library is an in-place sort
-and uses a constant extra space (allocated on the stack).
+The implementation of @code{qsort} in this library might not be an
+in-place sort and might thereby use an extra amount of memory to store
+the array.
 @end deftypefun
 
 @node Search/Sort Example
diff --git a/stdlib/Makefile b/stdlib/Makefile
index 0b154e57c5..1fdd84bad2 100644
--- a/stdlib/Makefile
+++ b/stdlib/Makefile
@@ -215,7 +215,6 @@  tests := \
   tst-qsort \
   tst-qsort2 \
   tst-qsort3 \
-  tst-qsort5 \
   tst-qsort6 \
   tst-quick_exit \
   tst-rand48 \
@@ -264,6 +263,7 @@  tests := \
 
 tests-internal := \
   tst-qsort4 \
+  tst-qsort5 \
   tst-strtod1i \
   tst-strtod3 \
   tst-strtod4 \
diff --git a/stdlib/qsort.c b/stdlib/qsort.c
index 62477010b6..931bbb160f 100644
--- a/stdlib/qsort.c
+++ b/stdlib/qsort.c
@@ -19,6 +19,7 @@ 
    Engineering a sort function; Jon Bentley and M. Douglas McIlroy;
    Software - Practice and Experience; Vol. 23 (11), 1249-1265, 1993.  */
 
+#include <errno.h>
 #include <limits.h>
 #include <memswap.h>
 #include <stdlib.h>
@@ -32,9 +33,13 @@  enum swap_type_t
   {
     SWAP_WORDS_64,
     SWAP_WORDS_32,
+    SWAP_VOID_ARG,
     SWAP_BYTES
   };
 
+typedef uint32_t __attribute__ ((__may_alias__)) u32_alias_t;
+typedef uint64_t __attribute__ ((__may_alias__)) u64_alias_t;
+
 /* If this function returns true, elements can be safely copied using word
    loads and stores.  Otherwise, it might not be safe.  BASE (as an integer)
    must be a multiple of the word alignment.  SIZE must be a multiple of
@@ -51,7 +56,6 @@  is_aligned (const void *base, size_t size, size_t wordsize)
 static inline void
 swap_words_64 (void * restrict a, void * restrict b, size_t n)
 {
-  typedef uint64_t __attribute__ ((__may_alias__)) u64_alias_t;
   do
    {
      n -= 8;
@@ -64,7 +68,6 @@  swap_words_64 (void * restrict a, void * restrict b, size_t n)
 static inline void
 swap_words_32 (void * restrict a, void * restrict b, size_t n)
 {
-  typedef uint32_t __attribute__ ((__may_alias__)) u32_alias_t;
   do
    {
      n -= 4;
@@ -88,43 +91,6 @@  do_swap (void * restrict a, void * restrict b, size_t size,
     __memswap (a, b, size);
 }
 
-/* Discontinue quicksort algorithm when partition gets below this size.
-   This particular magic number was chosen to work best on a Sun 4/260. */
-#define MAX_THRESH 4
-
-/* Stack node declarations used to store unfulfilled partition obligations. */
-typedef struct
-  {
-    char *lo;
-    char *hi;
-    size_t depth;
-  } stack_node;
-
-/* The stack needs log (total_elements) entries (we could even subtract
-   log(MAX_THRESH)).  Since total_elements has type size_t, we get as
-   upper bound for log (total_elements):
-   bits per byte (CHAR_BIT) * sizeof(size_t).  */
-enum { STACK_SIZE = CHAR_BIT * sizeof (size_t) };
-
-static inline stack_node *
-push (stack_node *top, char *lo, char *hi, size_t depth)
-{
-  top->lo = lo;
-  top->hi = hi;
-  top->depth = depth;
-  return ++top;
-}
-
-static inline stack_node *
-pop (stack_node *top, char **lo, char **hi, size_t *depth)
-{
-  --top;
-  *lo = top->lo;
-  *hi = top->hi;
-  *depth = top->depth;
-  return top;
-}
-
 /* Establish the heap condition at index K, that is, the key at K will
    not be less than either of its children, at 2 * K + 1 and 2 * K + 2
    (if they exist).  N is the last valid index. */
@@ -172,21 +138,25 @@  heapify (void *base, size_t size, size_t n, enum swap_type_t swap_type,
     }
 }
 
-/* A non-recursive heapsort, used on introsort implementation as a
-   fallback routine with worst-case performance of O(nlog n) and
-   worst-case space complexity of O(1).  It sorts the array starting
-   at BASE and ending at END (inclusive), with each element of SIZE
-   bytes.  The SWAP_TYPE is the callback function used to swap
-   elements, and CMP is the function used to compare elements.  */
+/* A non-recursive heapsort with worst-case performance of O(nlog n) and
+   worst-case space complexity of O(1).  It sorts the array starting at
+   BASE with n + 1 elements of SIZE bytes.  The SWAP_TYPE is the callback
+   function used to swap elements, and CMP is the function used to compare
+   elements.  */
 static void
-heapsort_r (void *base, void *end, size_t size, enum swap_type_t swap_type,
-	    __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
+heapsort_r (void *base, size_t n, size_t size, __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
 {
-  size_t n = ((uintptr_t) end - (uintptr_t) base) / size;
   if (n <= 1)
-    /* Handled by insertion sort.  */
     return;
 
+  enum swap_type_t swap_type;
+  if (is_aligned (base, size, 8))
+    swap_type = SWAP_WORDS_64;
+  else if (is_aligned (base, size, 4))
+    swap_type = SWAP_WORDS_32;
+  else
+    swap_type = SWAP_BYTES;
+
   /* Build the binary heap, largest value at the base[0].  */
   heapify (base, size, n, swap_type, cmp, arg);
 
@@ -208,226 +178,236 @@  heapsort_r (void *base, void *end, size_t size, enum swap_type_t swap_type,
     }
 }
 
-static inline void
-insertion_sort_qsort_partitions (void *const pbase, size_t total_elems,
-				 size_t size, enum swap_type_t swap_type,
-				 __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
+/* The maximum size in bytes required by mergesort that will be provided
+   through a buffer allocated in the stack.  */
+#define QSORT_STACK_SIZE  1024
+
+/* Elements larger than this value will be sorted through indirect sorting
+   to minimize the need to memory swap calls.  */
+#define INDIRECT_SORT_SIZE_THRES  32
+
+struct msort_param
 {
-  char *base_ptr = (char *) pbase;
-  char *const end_ptr = &base_ptr[size * (total_elems - 1)];
-  char *tmp_ptr = base_ptr;
-#define min(x, y) ((x) < (y) ? (x) : (y))
-  const size_t max_thresh = MAX_THRESH * size;
-  char *thresh = min(end_ptr, base_ptr + max_thresh);
-  char *run_ptr;
+  size_t s;
+  enum swap_type_t var;
+  __compar_d_fn_t cmp;
+  void *arg;
+  char *t;
+};
+
+static enum swap_type_t
+__attribute_used__
+msort_swap_type (void *const pbase, size_t size)
+{
+  if ((size & (sizeof (uint32_t) - 1)) == 0
+      && ((uintptr_t) pbase) % __alignof__ (uint32_t) == 0)
+    {
+      if (size == sizeof (uint32_t))
+	return SWAP_WORDS_32;
+      else if (size == sizeof (uint64_t)
+	       && ((uintptr_t) pbase) % __alignof__ (uint64_t) == 0)
+	return SWAP_WORDS_64;
+    }
+  return SWAP_BYTES;
+}
 
-  /* Find smallest element in first threshold and place it at the
-     array's beginning.  This is the smallest array element,
-     and the operation speeds up insertion sort's inner loop. */
+static void
+msort_with_tmp (const struct msort_param *p, void *b, size_t n)
+{
+  char *b1, *b2;
+  size_t n1, n2;
 
-  for (run_ptr = tmp_ptr + size; run_ptr <= thresh; run_ptr += size)
-    if (cmp (run_ptr, tmp_ptr, arg) < 0)
-      tmp_ptr = run_ptr;
+  if (n <= 1)
+    return;
 
-  if (tmp_ptr != base_ptr)
-    do_swap (tmp_ptr, base_ptr, size, swap_type);
+  n1 = n / 2;
+  n2 = n - n1;
+  b1 = b;
+  b2 = (char *) b + (n1 * p->s);
 
-  /* Insertion sort, running from left-hand-side up to right-hand-side.  */
+  msort_with_tmp (p, b1, n1);
+  msort_with_tmp (p, b2, n2);
 
-  run_ptr = base_ptr + size;
-  while ((run_ptr += size) <= end_ptr)
+  char *tmp = p->t;
+  const size_t s = p->s;
+  __compar_d_fn_t cmp = p->cmp;
+  void *arg = p->arg;
+  switch (p->var)
     {
-      tmp_ptr = run_ptr - size;
-      while (tmp_ptr != base_ptr && cmp (run_ptr, tmp_ptr, arg) < 0)
-        tmp_ptr -= size;
-
-      tmp_ptr += size;
-      if (tmp_ptr != run_ptr)
-        {
-          char *trav;
-
-          trav = run_ptr + size;
-          while (--trav >= run_ptr)
-            {
-              char c = *trav;
-              char *hi, *lo;
-
-              for (hi = lo = trav; (lo -= size) >= tmp_ptr; hi = lo)
-                *hi = *lo;
-              *hi = c;
-            }
-        }
+    case SWAP_WORDS_32:
+      while (n1 > 0 && n2 > 0)
+	{
+	  if (cmp (b1, b2, arg) <= 0)
+	    {
+	      *(u32_alias_t *) tmp = *(u32_alias_t *) b1;
+	      b1 += sizeof (u32_alias_t);
+	      --n1;
+	    }
+	  else
+	    {
+	      *(u32_alias_t *) tmp = *(u32_alias_t *) b2;
+	      b2 += sizeof (u32_alias_t);
+	      --n2;
+	    }
+	  tmp += sizeof (u32_alias_t);
+	}
+      break;
+    case SWAP_WORDS_64:
+      while (n1 > 0 && n2 > 0)
+	{
+	  if (cmp (b1, b2, arg) <= 0)
+	    {
+	      *(u64_alias_t *) tmp = *(u64_alias_t *) b1;
+	      b1 += sizeof (u64_alias_t);
+	      --n1;
+	    }
+	  else
+	    {
+	      *(u64_alias_t *) tmp = *(u64_alias_t *) b2;
+	      b2 += sizeof (u64_alias_t);
+	      --n2;
+	    }
+	  tmp += sizeof (u64_alias_t);
+	}
+      break;
+    case SWAP_VOID_ARG:
+      while (n1 > 0 && n2 > 0)
+	{
+	  if ((*cmp) (*(const void **) b1, *(const void **) b2, arg) <= 0)
+	    {
+	      *(void **) tmp = *(void **) b1;
+	      b1 += sizeof (void *);
+	      --n1;
+	    }
+	  else
+	    {
+	      *(void **) tmp = *(void **) b2;
+	      b2 += sizeof (void *);
+	      --n2;
+	    }
+	  tmp += sizeof (void *);
+	}
+    default:
+      while (n1 > 0 && n2 > 0)
+	{
+	  if (cmp (b1, b2, arg) <= 0)
+	    {
+	      tmp = (char *) __mempcpy (tmp, b1, s);
+	      b1 += s;
+	      --n1;
+	    }
+	  else
+	    {
+	      tmp = (char *) __mempcpy (tmp, b2, s);
+	      b2 += s;
+	      --n2;
+	    }
+	}
+      break;
     }
-}
-
-/* Order size using quicksort.  This implementation incorporates
-   four optimizations discussed in Sedgewick:
 
-   1. Non-recursive, using an explicit stack of pointer that store the
-      next array partition to sort.  To save time, this maximum amount
-      of space required to store an array of SIZE_MAX is allocated on the
-      stack.  Assuming a 32-bit (64 bit) integer for size_t, this needs
-      only 32 * sizeof(stack_node) == 256 bytes (for 64 bit: 1024 bytes).
-      Pretty cheap, actually.
-
-   2. Chose the pivot element using a median-of-three decision tree.
-      This reduces the probability of selecting a bad pivot value and
-      eliminates certain extraneous comparisons.
+  if (n1 > 0)
+    memcpy (tmp, b1, n1 * s);
+  memcpy (b, p->t, (n - n2) * s);
+}
 
-   3. Only quicksorts TOTAL_ELEMS / MAX_THRESH partitions, leaving
-      insertion sort to order the MAX_THRESH items within each partition.
-      This is a big win, since insertion sort is faster for small, mostly
-      sorted array segments.
+static void
+indirect_msort_with_tmp (const struct msort_param *p, void *b, size_t n,
+			 size_t s)
+{
+  /* Indirect sorting.  */
+  char *ip = (char *) b;
+  void **tp = (void **) (p->t + n * sizeof (void *));
+  void **t = tp;
+  void *tmp_storage = (void *) (tp + n);
 
-   4. The larger of the two sub-partitions is always pushed onto the
-      stack first, with the algorithm then concentrating on the
-      smaller partition.  This *guarantees* no more than log (total_elems)
-      stack size is needed (actually O(1) in this case)!  */
+  while ((void *) t < tmp_storage)
+    {
+      *t++ = ip;
+      ip += s;
+    }
+  msort_with_tmp (p, p->t + n * sizeof (void *), n);
+
+  /* tp[0] .. tp[n - 1] is now sorted, copy around entries of
+     the original array.  Knuth vol. 3 (2nd ed.) exercise 5.2-10.  */
+  char *kp;
+  size_t i;
+  for (i = 0, ip = (char *) b; i < n; i++, ip += s)
+    if ((kp = tp[i]) != ip)
+      {
+	size_t j = i;
+	char *jp = ip;
+	memcpy (tmp_storage, ip, s);
+
+	do
+	  {
+	    size_t k = (kp - (char *) b) / s;
+	    tp[j] = jp;
+	    memcpy (jp, kp, s);
+	    j = k;
+	    jp = kp;
+	    kp = tp[k];
+	  }
+	while (kp != ip);
+
+	tp[j] = jp;
+	memcpy (jp, tmp_storage, s);
+      }
+}
 
 void
 __qsort_r (void *const pbase, size_t total_elems, size_t size,
 	   __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
 {
-  char *base_ptr = (char *) pbase;
-
-  const size_t max_thresh = MAX_THRESH * size;
-
   if (total_elems <= 1)
-    /* Avoid lossage with unsigned arithmetic below.  */
     return;
 
-  enum swap_type_t swap_type;
-  if (is_aligned (pbase, size, 8))
-    swap_type = SWAP_WORDS_64;
-  else if (is_aligned (pbase, size, 4))
-    swap_type = SWAP_WORDS_32;
-  else
-    swap_type = SWAP_BYTES;
+  char tmp[QSORT_STACK_SIZE];
+  size_t total_size = total_elems * size;
+  char *buf;
 
-  /* Maximum depth before quicksort switches to heapsort.  */
-  size_t depth = 2 * (sizeof (size_t) * CHAR_BIT - 1
-		      - __builtin_clzl (total_elems));
+  if (total_size < sizeof buf)
+    buf = tmp;
+  else
+    {
+      int save = errno;
+      buf = malloc (total_size);
+      __set_errno (save);
+      if (buf == NULL)
+	{
+	  /* Fallback to heapsort in case of memory failure.  */
+	  heapsort_r (pbase, total_elems - 1, size, cmp, arg);
+	  return;
+	}
+    }
 
-  if (total_elems > MAX_THRESH)
+  if (size > INDIRECT_SORT_SIZE_THRES)
     {
-      char *lo = base_ptr;
-      char *hi = &lo[size * (total_elems - 1)];
-      stack_node stack[STACK_SIZE];
-      stack_node *top = push (stack, NULL, NULL, depth);
-
-      while (stack < top)
-        {
-          if (depth == 0)
-            {
-              heapsort_r (lo, hi, size, swap_type, cmp, arg);
-              top = pop (top, &lo, &hi, &depth);
-              continue;
-            }
-
-          char *left_ptr;
-          char *right_ptr;
-
-	  /* Select median value from among LO, MID, and HI. Rearrange
-	     LO and HI so the three values are sorted. This lowers the
-	     probability of picking a pathological pivot value and
-	     skips a comparison for both the LEFT_PTR and RIGHT_PTR in
-	     the while loops. */
-
-	  char *mid = lo + size * ((hi - lo) / size >> 1);
-
-	  if ((*cmp) ((void *) mid, (void *) lo, arg) < 0)
-	    do_swap (mid, lo, size, swap_type);
-	  if ((*cmp) ((void *) hi, (void *) mid, arg) < 0)
-	    do_swap (mid, hi, size, swap_type);
-	  else
-	    goto jump_over;
-	  if ((*cmp) ((void *) mid, (void *) lo, arg) < 0)
-	    do_swap (mid, lo, size, swap_type);
-	jump_over:;
-
-	  left_ptr  = lo + size;
-	  right_ptr = hi - size;
-
-	  /* Here's the famous ``collapse the walls'' section of quicksort.
-	     Gotta like those tight inner loops!  They are the main reason
-	     that this algorithm runs much faster than others. */
-	  do
-	    {
-	      while (left_ptr != mid
-		     && (*cmp) ((void *) left_ptr, (void *) mid, arg) < 0)
-		left_ptr += size;
-
-	      while (right_ptr != mid
-		     && (*cmp) ((void *) mid, (void *) right_ptr, arg) < 0)
-		right_ptr -= size;
-
-	      if (left_ptr < right_ptr)
-		{
-		  do_swap (left_ptr, right_ptr, size, swap_type);
-		  if (mid == left_ptr)
-		    mid = right_ptr;
-		  else if (mid == right_ptr)
-		    mid = left_ptr;
-		  left_ptr += size;
-		  right_ptr -= size;
-		}
-	      else if (left_ptr == right_ptr)
-		{
-		  left_ptr += size;
-		  right_ptr -= size;
-		  break;
-		}
-	    }
-	  while (left_ptr <= right_ptr);
-
-          /* Set up pointers for next iteration.  First determine whether
-             left and right partitions are below the threshold size.  If so,
-             ignore one or both.  Otherwise, push the larger partition's
-             bounds on the stack and continue sorting the smaller one. */
-
-          if ((size_t) (right_ptr - lo) <= max_thresh)
-            {
-              if ((size_t) (hi - left_ptr) <= max_thresh)
-		/* Ignore both small partitions. */
-		{
-		  top = pop (top, &lo, &hi, &depth);
-		  --depth;
-		}
-              else
-		{
-		  /* Ignore small left partition. */
-		  lo = left_ptr;
-		  --depth;
-		}
-            }
-          else if ((size_t) (hi - left_ptr) <= max_thresh)
-	    /* Ignore small right partition. */
-		{
-		  hi = right_ptr;
-		  --depth;
-		}
-          else if ((right_ptr - lo) > (hi - left_ptr))
-            {
-	      /* Push larger left partition indices. */
-              top = push (top, lo, right_ptr, depth - 1);
-              lo = left_ptr;
-            }
-          else
-            {
-	      /* Push larger right partition indices. */
-              top = push (top, left_ptr, hi, depth - 1);
-              hi = right_ptr;
-            }
-        }
+      const struct msort_param msort_param =
+	{
+	  .s = sizeof (void *),
+	  .cmp = cmp,
+	  .arg = arg,
+	  .var = SWAP_VOID_ARG,
+	  .t = buf,
+	};
+      indirect_msort_with_tmp (&msort_param, pbase, total_elems, size);
+    }
+  else
+    {
+      const struct msort_param msort_param =
+	{
+	  .s = size,
+	  .cmp = cmp,
+	  .arg = arg,
+	  .var = msort_swap_type (pbase, size),
+	  .t = buf,
+	};
+      msort_with_tmp (&msort_param, pbase, total_elems);
     }
 
-  /* Once the BASE_PTR array is partially sorted by quicksort the rest
-     is completely sorted using insertion sort, since this is efficient
-     for partitions below MAX_THRESH size. BASE_PTR points to the beginning
-     of the array to sort, and END_PTR points at the very last element in
-     the array (*not* one beyond it!). */
-  insertion_sort_qsort_partitions (pbase, total_elems, size, swap_type, cmp,
-				   arg);
+  if (buf != tmp)
+    free (buf);
 }
 libc_hidden_def (__qsort_r)
 weak_alias (__qsort_r, qsort_r)
diff --git a/stdlib/tst-qsort4.c b/stdlib/tst-qsort4.c
index a7abaa1a37..4cf373f22e 100644
--- a/stdlib/tst-qsort4.c
+++ b/stdlib/tst-qsort4.c
@@ -30,35 +30,12 @@  cmp (const void *a1, const void *b1, void *closure)
   return *a - *b;
 }
 
-/* Wrapper around heapsort_r that set ups the required variables.  */
-static void
-heapsort_wrapper (void *const pbase, size_t total_elems, size_t size,
-                  __compar_d_fn_t cmp, void *arg)
-{
-  char *base_ptr = (char *) pbase;
-  char *lo = base_ptr;
-  char *hi = &lo[size * (total_elems - 1)];
-
-  if (total_elems <= 1)
-    /* Avoid lossage with unsigned arithmetic below.  */
-    return;
-
-  enum swap_type_t swap_type;
-  if (is_aligned (pbase, size, 8))
-    swap_type = SWAP_WORDS_64;
-  else if (is_aligned (pbase, size, 4))
-    swap_type = SWAP_WORDS_32;
-  else
-    swap_type = SWAP_BYTES;
-  heapsort_r (lo, hi, size, swap_type, cmp, arg);
-}
-
 static void
 check_one_sort (signed char *array, int length)
 {
   signed char *copy = xmalloc (length);
   memcpy (copy, array, length);
-  heapsort_wrapper (copy, length, 1, cmp, NULL);
+  heapsort_r (copy, length - 1, 1, cmp, NULL);
 
   /* Verify that the result is sorted.  */
   for (int i = 1; i < length; ++i)
diff --git a/stdlib/tst-qsort5.c b/stdlib/tst-qsort5.c
index d3a88c30f8..39cce077b6 100644
--- a/stdlib/tst-qsort5.c
+++ b/stdlib/tst-qsort5.c
@@ -27,6 +27,55 @@ 
 #include <support/check.h>
 #include <support/support.h>
 
+#include "qsort.c"
+
+typedef void (*func_r_wrapper) (void *, size_t, size_t, __compar_d_fn_t,
+				void *);
+
+static void
+mergesort_r_wrapper (void *pbase, size_t total_elems, size_t size,
+		     int (*cmp)(const void *, const void *, void *),
+		     void *arg)
+{
+  size_t total_size = total_elems * size;
+  void *buf = xmalloc (total_size);
+
+  if (size > INDIRECT_SORT_SIZE_THRES)
+    {
+      const struct msort_param msort_param =
+	{
+	  .s = sizeof (void *),
+	  .cmp = cmp,
+	  .arg = arg,
+	  .var = SWAP_VOID_ARG,
+	  .t = buf,
+	};
+      indirect_msort_with_tmp (&msort_param, pbase, total_elems, size);
+    }
+  else
+    {
+      const struct msort_param msort_param =
+	{
+	  .s = size,
+	  .cmp = cmp,
+	  .arg = arg,
+	  .var = msort_swap_type (pbase, size),
+	  .t = buf,
+	};
+      msort_with_tmp (&msort_param, pbase, total_elems);
+    }
+
+  free (buf);
+}
+
+static void
+heapsort_r_wrapper (void *pbase, size_t total_elems, size_t size,
+		    int (*cmp)(const void *, const void *, void *),
+		    void *arg)
+{
+  heapsort_r (pbase, total_elems - 1, size, cmp, arg);
+}
+
 struct context
 {
   /* Called the gas value in the paper.  This value is larger than all
@@ -135,11 +184,11 @@  compare_counter (const void *l1, const void *r1, void *closure)
 /* Count the comparisons required for an adversarial permutation of
    length N.  */
 static unsigned long long int
-count_comparisons (size_t n)
+count_comparisons (func_r_wrapper func, size_t n)
 {
   int *array = create_permutation (n);
   unsigned long long int counter = 0;
-  qsort_r (array, n, sizeof (*array), compare_counter, &counter);
+  func (array, n, sizeof (*array), compare_counter, &counter);
   free (array);
   return counter;
 }
@@ -149,13 +198,19 @@  count_comparisons (size_t n)
 static void
 check_one_n (size_t n)
 {
-  unsigned long long int count = count_comparisons (n);
-  double factor = count / (n * log (count));
-  printf ("info: length %zu: %llu comparisons ~ %f * n * log (n)\n",
-          n, count, factor);
-  /* This is an arbitrary factor which is true for the current
+  unsigned long long int m_count = count_comparisons (mergesort_r_wrapper, n);
+  double m_factor = m_count / (n * log (m_count));
+
+  unsigned long long int h_count = count_comparisons (heapsort_r_wrapper, n);
+  double h_factor = h_count / (n * log (h_count));
+
+  printf ("info: length %zu: (%llu, %llu) comparisons ~ (%f, %f) * n * log (n)\n",
+          n, m_count, h_count, m_factor, h_factor);
+
+  /* This is an arbitrary factor which is true for the largest current
      implementation across a wide range of sizes.  */
-  TEST_VERIFY (factor <= 4.5);
+  double factor = fmax (m_factor, h_factor);
+  TEST_VERIFY (factor <= 2.5);
 }
 
 static int